What's a Christmas song?
We recently had a lively discussion in the family online chat and later at a seasonal gathering regarding what constitutes a Christmas song. My criteria aren't exactly defined, so I might change my mind, depending on my mood. But key to making the decision is that the song needs to invoke an emotion. Traditionally a happy, warm, fuzzy one. But sometimes these days it's a bittersweet one, remembering what was and isn't likely to happen again. Silver Bells - I'd like to say no, but begrudgingly yes. I liked it when I was a child, I think because of the melody. Same applies to the likes of Rudolph, Winter Wonderland, White Christmas, Baby it's Cold Outside etc. Too bland and contrived? Joy to the World - yes, especially when over the top, like these folks do. We did this in our community choir Christmas concert, and I had the pleasure of getting the soprano descant blasted at me from close range. So much fun! Hark the Herald Angels Sing, another good one. O Holy ...