What's a Christmas song?

We recently had a lively discussion in the family online chat and later at a seasonal gathering regarding what constitutes a Christmas song. My criteria aren't exactly defined, so I might change my mind, depending on my mood. 

But key to making the decision is that the song needs to invoke an emotion. Traditionally a happy, warm, fuzzy one. But sometimes these days it's a bittersweet one, remembering what was and isn't likely to happen again. 

Silver Bells - I'd like to say no, but begrudgingly yes. I liked it when I was a child, I think because of the melody. Same applies to the likes of Rudolph, Winter Wonderland, White Christmas, Baby it's Cold Outside etc. Too bland and contrived?

Joy to the World - yes, especially when over the top, like these folks do. We did this in our community choir Christmas concert, and I had the pleasure of getting the soprano descant blasted at me from close range. So much fun! Hark the Herald Angels Sing, another good one.

O Holy Night - cheating, and they've even done it better with maturity. It's not so much that this is a Christmas song, but powerful, especially with the right instrument!

Away in a Manger - kinda, but this one doesn't really move me. Too descriptive, not heart tugging?

The Wexford Carol - cheating by using the Allison version, but yes. This song has legs! It's 800 years old.

I'll Be There Christmas Eve - yes, the feels! No mention of baby Jesus, which I usually think is important.

First Christmas - same

River - for some reason, I want to exclude this one. I love the song, but it's not Christmassy. I'm not saying this vote makes sense, considering the preceding two get an "aye".

Christmas in Prison - strangely, no. Why those two above and not this?

White Winter Hymnal - no, even though I like this

Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer - not a fan of the novelty Christmas genre. We did Little St. Nick at our concert, same "nay" vote. Six White Boomers, Santa Drank All Daddy's Beer: bah, humbug.

What do you think?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

WE Cruise the Rhine

Image
In celebration of a significant number of decades of wedded bliss, we did a river cruise on the Rhine, courtesy Ama Waterways. The Route I've drawn this by hand, so our actual distance covered was likely more, over 800km. The plan She has consented to do carry-on only luggage, as we have a couple of multi-hour periods where a big bag would be painful to deal with. We reached a good agreement on what is really essential travel stuff. Itinerary Monday May 12th to Montreal, then overnight to Amsterdam arriving May 13. No one had announced direct flight when we booked all this. Stay in Amsterdam at the Rho Hotel See the sites in Amsterdam until we board our boat the AmaPrima on May 14. May 15, we stay docked the first night, and go on a canal tour in Amsterdam in the morning May 16, we dock at Dusseldorf walking tour of Dussledorf walking tour of Cologne May 17, we dock at Rudesheim bike tour of the Rheingau Siegfried's Mechanical Music cabinet May 18, we dock at Ludwigshafen (Mann...
Read more

Nerd alert: heat pumps vs. oil-fired hydronic baseboards analysis

Image
We are heading for a cold snap this week, with a low of -15C forecast for Tuesday. What temperature does it make sense to turn up the thermostat so the oil-fired heat takes over from labouring heat pumps? Well, I'm glad you asked! I looked at our oil consumption for 5 years before we installed heat pumps. In the non-heating summer season, we used oil to heat just domestic hot water, to the tune of about 2.8 liters per day. We used a measurable amount of oil annually, so taking 2.8 * 365 from that total gives the annual oil consumption for heating only. The annual heating degree day total here is 3600, meaning that the daily outside temperature is, on average, 3600/365 (i.e. 10) degrees lower than our desired home interior temperature. My outside temperature sensor agrees, maybe a bit warmer. Oil is 10.7 KWh per liter, so (mutter, mutter) heating our house with oil consumes 4.48 KWh per heating degree day, or 186 watts per degree difference between inside and outside. I'm measur...
Read more

Almost a PV catastrophe

Image
 We recently has PV solar panels installed on the roof.The day we turned them on was cloudy, and they produced almost nothing. 18 cents worth of electricity. The next day was very sunny and resulted in about 75% of their designed power production midday and about $6 worth of energy, which is very good for a short day in December.  Then we had two good sized snowstorms just before Christmas, and the resulting accumulation on the panels shut down production to almost nothing. Here's the week centred on Christmas Day.  So what happened on December 27th to restore production? Mid-morning, the sun and warmth was finally uncovering the panels from their snowy blanket. In the late morning after taking this picture, while I was checking the oil prior to our road trip, an angel came to me in a dream and suggested moving the car back from the house.  Just before 2:00PM, while doomscrolling on the couch,  I heard a loud rumble and felt the house shake a bit. Going outside,...
Read more